FAROOQ MUGHAL(SMC-PRIVATE) LIMITED
EN
Principles and comparison

Five schools of jurisprudence: Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi‘i, Hanbali and Jafari

Many fundamental shares are shared by all schools. Differences arise in particular family situations, disposal of the residue and certain special cases.

The five schools, one by one

Choose a school: a short introduction appears, with the examples where that school's result differs from the other schools, each with that school's coloured bar. Open an example and press “Back” to return to the same place.

Choose a school above.

Basic principles: the full summary

Everything in the “what the calculation covers” picture (PDF), here in the same order with coloured bars. Each part lists its related examples; after it come the full details and sources for each topic.

1

The 23 heirs and the 9 distant kindred

Who the calculation covers

What is it? The first step in any division is to see which close relatives are alive. In all five schools the calculation runs on these 23 basic heirs, in five groups:

Children (4)

Son, daughter, son’s son, son’s daughter

Parents and above (5)

Father, mother, paternal grandfather, paternal grandmother, maternal grandmother

Spouses (2)

Husband, wife (one to four)

Brothers and sisters (6)

Full brother and sister, paternal half-brother and sister, maternal half-brother and sister

Nephews, uncles, cousins (6)

Son of a full or paternal half-brother; full or paternal half-uncle; son of a full or half-uncle

Distant kindred (9)

Maternal grandfather, maternal uncle and aunt, paternal aunt, sister’s son and daughter, brother’s daughter, daughter’s son and daughter. They inherit only when none of the 23 is alive (apart from a spouse). The Hanafi, Hanbali and Ja‘fari schools calculate them; the classical Maliki and Shafi‘i view gives the estate to the treasury.

2

The fixed shares

Set by the Quran itself

The rule: The Quran itself fixes the shares of some close relatives, and they are paid first. There are six fixed shares; in each box the coloured strip shows how much of the whole estate it is:

1/2

A single daughter (no son); or the husband when there are no children

1/4

The husband when there are children; or the wife when there are none

1/8

The wife (or wives) when there are children

2/3

Two or more daughters (no son)

1/3

The mother when there are no children and fewer than two siblings

1/6

Father and mother, each, when there are children

Quran: An-Nisa 4:11, 4:12, 4:176

3

Exclusion by a nearer heir

The nearer relative shuts out the farther one

The rule: The nearer a relative is to the deceased, the more they shut out those farther away. This is called hajb (exclusion). The app writes next to every excluded heir who excluded them:

If there is a son

Son’s son، Brother، Nephew، Uncle

If there is a father

Grandfather، Brothers and sisters

If there is a mother

Paternal grandmother، Maternal grandmother

If there is a full brother

Paternal half-brother، Nephew، Uncle

Example: a son and a full brother

  • Son whole estate

Full brother: nothing (all five schools)

4

The order of residuaries

Who takes what is left after the fixed shares

The rule: After the fixed shares, what is left goes to the nearest male relative (the residuary), in this order. A daughter with a son, and a sister with a brother, become residuaries too, the male taking twice the female.

  1. Son
  2. Son’s son
  3. Father
  4. Grandfather
  5. Full brother
  6. Paternal half-brother
  7. Full brother’s son
  8. Half-brother’s son
  9. Full uncle
  10. Half uncle
  11. Uncle’s son

Example: one son and one daughter

All five schools

  • Son 2/3
  • Daughter 1/3

The son takes twice the daughter

Example: one daughter and a full brother

Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi‘i, Hanbali

  • Daughter 1/2
  • Full brother 1/2

The daughter’s fixed half; the other half to the brother as residuary

The same example

Ja‘fari

  • Daughter whole estate

In Fiqh Ja‘fari siblings do not inherit alongside children; the daughter takes her half and the rest by return

Hadith: “Give the shares to those entitled to them; what is left goes to the nearest male” (Sahih al-Bukhari 6732, Sahih Muslim 1615)

5

The two ‘Umariyyah cases

A spouse, the mother and the father, with no children

The problem With no children the mother’s share is a third of the estate. But if the husband takes half and the mother a third of the whole, the mother gets more than the father, although at the same level the man takes twice the woman.

The solution: ‘Umar ruled that after the spouse’s share, the mother takes a third of what is left and the father the rest. The Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi‘i and Hanbali schools follow this. In Fiqh Ja‘fari (the view of Ibn ‘Abbas) the mother takes a third of the whole estate.

Case 1: husband, mother, father

Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi‘i, Hanbali

  • Husband 1/2
  • Mother 1/6
  • Father 1/3

The mother takes a third of the remaining half = a sixth of the whole

Case 1

Ja‘fari

  • Husband 1/2
  • Mother 1/3
  • Father 1/6

The mother takes a third of the whole

Case 2: wife, mother, father

Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi‘i, Hanbali

  • Wife 1/4
  • Mother 1/4
  • Father 1/2

The mother takes a third of the remaining three quarters = a quarter of the whole

Case 2

Ja‘fari

  • Wife 1/4
  • Mother 1/3
  • Father 5/12

The mother a third of the whole, the rest to the father

6

‘Awl (proportional reduction)

When the shares add up to more than the estate

What is it? Sometimes the Quran’s fixed shares add up to more than the whole estate (100%).

The solution: In ‘Umar’s time the Companions agreed that instead of cutting one heir, everyone’s share is reduced in the same proportion. Fiqh Ja‘fari has no ‘awl: the spouse keeps the full share and the shortfall comes from the daughters’ or sisters’ share.

Example: husband and two full sisters

Hanafi, Maliki, Shafi‘i, Hanbali

1/2 + 2/3 = 7/6 → seven parts

  • Husband 3/7
  • Two full sisters 4/7

Each sister 2/7

The same example

Ja‘fari

  • Husband 1/2
  • Two full sisters 1/2

The husband keeps his full half; the shortfall falls on the sisters

7

Radd (return)

When something is left after the shares and there is no residuary

What is it? The opposite of ‘awl: after all the shares something is left, and there is no residuary such as a son, brother or uncle to take it.

The solution: In the Hanafi, Hanbali and Ja‘fari schools the remainder is returned to the sharers in proportion to their shares, but not to a husband or wife. The classical Maliki and Shafi‘i view sends it to the public treasury; the app shows that remainder separately.

Example: mother and one daughter

Hanafi, Hanbali, Ja‘fari

1/6 + 1/2 = 2/3; the remaining 1/3 goes back in the same ratio (1:3)

  • Mother 1/4
  • Daughter 3/4

The same example

Maliki, Shafi‘i (classical view)

  • Mother 1/6
  • Daughter 1/2
  • Remainder (treasury) 1/3

Example: wife and one daughter

Hanafi, Hanbali, Ja‘fari

  • Wife 1/8
  • Daughter 7/8

The wife keeps only her 1/8; all the rest returns to the daughter

8

Grandfather with brothers and sisters

A well-known difference among the Companions

What is it? The father is no longer alive, and the grandfather is there together with full or paternal brothers and sisters.

Two views: Abu Bakr: the grandfather stands in the father’s place and shuts out the siblings; the Hanafi school follows this. Zayd ibn Thabit: the grandfather shares with the siblings and takes the better of two methods; the Maliki, Shafi‘i and Hanbali schools follow this, and in Fiqh Ja‘fari too the grandfather shares like a brother.

Example: grandfather and one full brother

Hanafi

  • Grandfather whole estate

Full brother: nothing

The same example

Maliki, Shafi‘i, Hanbali, Ja‘fari

  • Grandfather 1/2
  • Full brother 1/2

Half each

9

Al-Mushtarakah (al-Himariyyah)

A famous ruling of ‘Umar

What is it? A woman dies leaving her husband, her mother, two maternal half-brothers and one full brother. The fixed shares (husband 1/2, mother 1/6, maternal brothers 1/3) use up everything, so the full brother, a residuary, is left with nothing.

The ruling: The full brothers said: “Suppose our father was a donkey (himar) – we still have the same mother!” ‘Umar let them share the maternal brothers’ third equally. The Maliki and Shafi‘i schools follow this; in the Hanafi and Hanbali schools (the view of ‘Ali) the full brother gets nothing. In Fiqh Ja‘fari no sibling inherits while the mother is alive.

Husband, mother, two maternal half-brothers, one full brother

Maliki, Shafi‘i

  • Husband 1/2
  • Mother 1/6
  • Three brothers 1/3

Each brother 1/9

The same example

Hanafi, Hanbali

  • Husband 1/2
  • Mother 1/6
  • Two maternal half-brothers 1/3

Each maternal brother 1/6; full brother: nothing

The same example

Ja‘fari

  • Husband 1/2
  • Mother 1/2

The mother takes 1/3 by share and the rest by return; the siblings are excluded

10

Al-Akdariyyah

Zayd ibn Thabit’s solution

What is it? The name comes from kadar (confusion), because it is a hard case: a woman leaves her husband, her mother, the grandfather and one full sister.

The solution: In the Maliki, Shafi‘i and Hanbali schools everyone first gets a share with ‘awl (husband 1/2, mother 1/3, grandfather 1/6, sister 1/2); then the grandfather’s and sister’s shares are pooled and the grandfather takes twice the sister, so the estate is divided into 27 parts. In the Hanafi school the grandfather excludes the sister. In Fiqh Ja‘fari neither the grandfather nor the sister inherits while the mother is alive.

Husband, mother, grandfather, full sister

Maliki, Shafi‘i, Hanbali

  • Husband 9/27
  • Mother 6/27
  • Grandfather 8/27
  • Full sister 4/27

27 parts: husband 9, mother 6, grandfather 8, sister 4

The same example

Hanafi

  • Husband 1/2
  • Mother 1/3
  • Grandfather 1/6

Full sister: nothing

The same example

Ja‘fari

  • Husband 1/2
  • Mother 1/2

Grandfather and sister excluded

11

Sisters with daughters

a ruling of the Prophet (peace be upon him)

With daughters but no son, a full or paternal half-sister takes what remains. Ibn Mas‘ud gave this ruling as the Prophet (peace be upon him) had ruled. In Fiqh Ja‘fari the son’s daughter and the sister do not inherit alongside a daughter, so here the daughter takes the whole estate.

Example: daughter, son’s daughter, sister

  • Daughter 1/2
  • Son’s daughter 1/6
  • Sister the rest 1/3

Sahih al-Bukhari 6736

12

Exact fractions, clear rounding

no money goes missing

The app works every share as an exact fraction (such as 8/27), not a decimal estimate. When an amount is entered it shows each heir’s amount, and states any rounding of the last units separately so the total adds up. Every result shows the amount and the percentage side by side.

Example: 1/3 of 1,000,000

333,333.33, with the rounding difference shown separately

Shares, exclusion and residuary heirs

Fixed-share heirs are eligible heirs with a prescribed share in the applicable circumstances. Residuary heirs may receive what remains after fixed shares. Exclusion (hajb) means a nearer relative’s presence reduces or removes another person’s share. Knowing the relationship alone is insufficient; the other relatives present also matter.

RelationshipUsual prescribed share and condition
HusbandOne half without an inheriting descendant; one quarter with one.
Wife or wivesOne quarter collectively without an inheriting descendant; one eighth collectively with one.
Daughter or daughtersWithout a son: one daughter receives one half; two or more receive two thirds collectively. With a son, they share the residue 2:1.
MotherOne sixth with an inheriting descendant or at least two siblings; usually one third otherwise. The two ‘Umariyya cases are separate.
FatherOne sixth with a male inheriting descendant; one sixth plus the residue with only female inheriting descendants; a residuary heir without an inheriting descendant.
Maternal siblingsWithout an inheriting descendant or father/grandfather: one receives one sixth; two or more share one third equally, male and female alike.

This is a basic outline; complete conditions, exclusion, ‘awl and radd may change the result. Al-Nisa 4:11 · 4:12 · 4:176

Fiqh Jafari: These fixed shares come from the Quran, so they are the same in Fiqh Jafari. The difference is that heirs are in three classes: while the first class (parents and children) exists, the second (grandparents and brothers and sisters) and the third (paternal and maternal uncles and aunts) do not inherit, so maternal half-siblings are also excluded while the mother is alive. There is no separate rule of residuary heirs: what is left after the fixed shares returns to the same blood relatives in proportion to their shares.

See the differences through examples

Each row assumes only the listed relatives, with no additional heir or special impediment.

CaseHanafiMalikiShafi‘iHanbaliJafari
Father + paternal grandmotherFather: all
Paternal grandmother: excluded
Father: all
Paternal grandmother: excluded
Father: all
Paternal grandmother: excluded
Father: 5/6 (83.33%)
Paternal grandmother: 1/6 (16.67%)
Father: all
Grandmother: excluded
Paternal grandfather + full brotherGrandfather: all
Brother: excluded
Each: one halfEach: one halfEach: one halfEach: one half
Akdariyya: husband, mother, grandfather and one full sisterHusband: 1/2 (50.00%)
Mother: 1/3 (33.33%)
Grandfather: 1/6 (16.67%)
Sister: zero
In this special case: husband 9/27 (33.33%), mother 6/27 (22.22%), grandfather 8/27 (29.63%), sister 4/27 (14.81%).Husband: 1/2 (50.00%)
Mother: 1/2 (50.00%)
Grandfather and sister: excluded
One daughter, no residuary heirOne half + the residue by raddOne half; the residue is separate under the classical public-treasury approachOne half; the residue is separate under the classical public-treasury approachOne half + the residue by raddOne half + the residue by radd

The radd row follows the classical approach assuming an organised public treasury. Later fatwas may differ in practice. It would be inaccurate to combine every historical opinion within a school into one result.

The two ‘Umariyya cases: parents and a spouse

With a husband, mother and father: the husband takes one half, the mother one third of the residue (one sixth of the whole), and the father one third of the whole. With a wife, mother and father: the wife takes one quarter, the mother one third of the residue (one quarter of the whole), and the father one half. These cases assume no inheriting descendant and no two or more siblings reducing the mother to one sixth.

Fiqh Jafari: The Umariyyatan method is not used. The mother receives one third of the whole estate, when there are no brothers and sisters who reduce her share, and the rest goes to the father. With a husband: husband 1/2, mother 1/3, father 1/6. With a wife: wife 1/4, mother 1/3, father 5/12.

Siblings inheriting with a grandfather

A living father excludes the grandfather. In the father’s absence, the Hanafi approach excludes full or paternal siblings when the grandfather is present. Under the relevant general rule of the other three schools, the option most favourable to the grandfather is selected.

  • Without other fixed-share heirs: sharing as a sibling, or one third of the whole estate.
  • With fixed-share heirs: sharing the residue, one third of the residue, or one sixth of the whole estate; the most favourable eligible option applies.
  • Akdariyya is a specific exception, illustrated separately above.

When full and paternal siblings are present together, the rules of mu‘adda apply. In this edition, this branch prompts further review for non-Hanafi results instead of automatic calculation. The marked special combinations of Malikiyya and Shibh Malikiyya are also withheld from automatic calculation.

Fiqh Jafari: The grandfather and the brothers and sisters are both in the second class and inherit together. The paternal grandfather takes like a full or paternal brother, and the grandmother like a sister; for example, a grandfather and one full brother take half each. If a parent or a child is alive, neither the grandfather nor the brothers and sisters inherit.

Search the detailed research →

Mushtaraka / Himariyya

Example: husband, mother, two maternal brothers and one full brother. The husband receives one half and the mother one sixth. Under the Hanafi and Hanbali approaches, the maternal brothers share one third; no residue remains for the full brother. Under the Maliki and Shafi‘i approaches, the eligible full and maternal siblings share that one third equally; in this example each of the three receives 1/9.

Calculate this example →

Fiqh Jafari: The mother is in the first class, so in this example none of the brothers inherit. The husband receives 1/2 and the mother 1/2: one third is her fixed share and the rest comes back to her as radd.

‘Awl and radd: two different operations

‘Awl: prescribed shares exceed the estate

For example, a husband and two full sisters: one half plus two thirds totals 7/6. After ‘awl, the husband receives 3/7 and the sisters collectively 4/7. Each sister receives 2/7.

Fiqh Jafari: There is no awl. If the shares add up to more than the estate, the shortfall is taken from the share of the daughters or of the full and paternal sisters, and everyone else receives a full share. In this same example the husband takes 1/2 and the two sisters together take 1/2.

Radd: property remains after fixed shares, with no residuary heir

In this edition’s Hanafi and Hanbali approaches, the residue is returned proportionally to eligible fixed-share heirs other than spouses. Maliki and Shafi‘i results show the classical approach assuming an organised public treasury, with the residue displayed separately. Later fatwas and the actual state of the treasury may change the ruling.

A husband or wife alone is not automatically given the whole estate. Disposal of the residue, distant kindred and the applicable jurisprudential and legal approach require further verification.

Fiqh Jafari: Radd applies, and the leftover returns to the blood relatives in proportion to their shares; there is no radd to the husband or wife, except when the husband is the only heir. The case of only a husband or only a wife is below, under «When there is no heir».

Distant kindred (dhawu al-arham): maternal grandfather, daughter's children, maternal uncles and aunts, paternal aunts

Heirs are of three kinds: fixed-share heirs (ashab al-furud), residuaries (asabah), and distant kindred (dhawu al-arham). Distant kindred are close relatives who have neither a fixed share nor residuary status. Classical books list eleven categories of them, such as:

  • A daughter's children, and a sister's children
  • A brother's daughters, and the children of a maternal half-brother
  • Paternal aunts, maternal uncles, maternal aunts, a paternal uncle's daughters, and the father's maternal half-brother
  • The maternal grandfather (the mother's father), and those grandmothers whose link runs through a man who is not himself an heir

Book of inheritance: the chapter on distant kindred (full Arabic text and translation)

The difference between the maternal grandmother and the maternal grandfather

The maternal grandmother is a fixed-share heir: if the mother is not alive she receives one sixth, which she shares with the paternal grandmother if both are present. The maternal grandfather is a male relative through the mother, so in fiqh terminology he is called a “false grandfather” (jadd fasid), meaning a grandfather who is not on the list of heirs. He is counted among the distant kindred.

Book of inheritance: inheritance of the maternal and paternal grandmothers

When do distant kindred inherit?

According to the scholars who accept them as heirs, distant kindred inherit only when there is no fixed-share heir and no residuary. A husband or wife is the exception: they take their share and the remainder goes to the distant kindred. If a fixed-share relative is present, such as a lone daughter, the surplus is first returned to that relative (radd), and the distant kindred receive nothing.

Book of inheritance: radd takes priority over the distant kindred

Evidence

  • Quran: “And those of blood relationship are nearer to one another in the decree of Allah” (Urdu translation: Maulana Muhammad Ibrahim Junagarhi). Surah al-Anfal 8:75 · Surah al-Ahzab 33:6
  • Hadith: the Prophet ﷺ said that the maternal uncle is the heir of one who has no heir. Narrated by Abu Dawud, al-Tirmidhi, Ibn Majah and Ahmad. The hadith and its commentary

Positions of the schools

  • Hanafi and Hanbali: Distant kindred are heirs. This view is reported from Umar, Ali and Abdullah ibn Masud.
  • Maliki and Shafii, original school view: Distant kindred are not heirs; the remainder goes to the public treasury. This is the view of Zayd ibn Thabit.
  • Maliki and Shafii, later scholars: Where the public treasury is not properly and justly organised, radd comes first and then the estate goes to the distant kindred. The Maliki shaykhs agreed on this from the third Islamic century, and Shafii scholars gave the same ruling.

Fiqh Jafari: There is no separate category of distant kindred. Maternal grandparents, daughters' children, sisters' children, paternal aunts, maternal uncles and maternal aunts all inherit in their own places within the same three classes, and in each class the nearer relative excludes the more distant one. For example, if there is no son or daughter, a daughter's son inherits in the first class in his mother's place.

How is it divided among them?

There are two well-known methods. Hanafi fiqh uses the method of “kinship” (ahl al-qarabah): the distant kindred are ranked by nearness like residuaries, and the nearest comes first. Hanbali fiqh uses the method of “substitution” (ahl al-tanzil): each one is put in the place of the heir through whom they are related to the deceased. For example, the maternal aunt takes the place of the mother and the paternal aunt the place of the father. Among Shafii and Maliki scholars who accept them as heirs, this is also the more correct view.

Book of inheritance: placing distant kindred in the rank of the heir who connects them

How does the family tree calculate it?

The tree has nine distant relatives: maternal grandfather, daughter's son, daughter's daughter, sister's son, sister's daughter, brother's daughter, paternal aunt, maternal uncle and maternal aunt. When there is no close heir, their percentages are worked out as follows:

  • Hanafi: Four ranks, in this order: (1) a daughter's children, (2) the maternal grandfather, (3) siblings' children, (4) paternal aunt, maternal uncle and maternal aunt. If someone of an earlier rank is present, the later ranks are excluded. This is Abu Hanifa's order; Abu Yusuf and Muhammad put siblings' children before the maternal grandfather. Within a rank a male receives twice a female. In the fourth rank the father's-side relative (paternal aunt) receives two thirds and the mother's-side relatives (maternal uncle and aunt) one third. For siblings' children Abu Yusuf looks at the individuals themselves and Imam Muhammad at their parents; the tree shows Imam Muhammad's result, and where Abu Yusuf's result differs it is shown too.
  • Hanbali: “Substitution” (tanzil): each relative stands in the place of the heir through whom they are linked. A daughter's children take the daughter's place, a sister's children the sister's, a brother's daughter the brother's, the paternal aunt the father's, and the maternal grandfather, maternal uncle and maternal aunt the mother's. The shares of those heirs are found by the normal rules, and each share is divided equally among the relatives standing in that place, male and female equal.
  • With a husband or wife: They take their full share (husband one half, wife one quarter), and the rest is divided among the distant kindred by the same method.
  • Maliki and Shafii: The tree shows their original view (public treasury) and does not produce percentages.
  • Assumption: The calculation assumes that the siblings through whom a relative is linked are full siblings, and that a daughter's children descend from one daughter. If the real situation differs, consult a scholar.

Sources: Imam al-Sarakhsi, al-Mabsut, chapter on distant kindred · al-Fatawa al-Hindiyyah (6/461) · Egyptian Dar al-Ifta, fatwa 3145 · Shaykh Ibn Baz, chapter on the inheritance of distant kindred. Links are at the end of this section.

In Pakistan

Pakistani courts generally follow Hanafi fiqh in inheritance matters, so here distant kindred inherit according to the Hanafi rules. In such a case, consult a scholar or lawyer with the full family details.

Sources for this section

Book of inheritance: the chapter on distant kindred

This is the chapter of the classical inheritance book Kitab al-Fara'id on distant kindred: relatives such as the maternal grandfather, a daughter's children, a sister's children, maternal uncles and aunts and paternal aunts. It explains when these relatives inherit and how the estate is divided among them. Its full Arabic text, with Urdu and English translation, is on our site, taken from the Mawarith scholarly library.

See the text →

Al-Mawsuah al-Fiqhiyyah (Egypt): distant kindred in the Maliki and Shafii schools

This is the part of the Egyptian fiqh encyclopaedia that covers distant kindred in the Maliki and Shafi'i schools. The original position of both schools was that distant kindred do not inherit and the remainder goes to the public treasury (bayt al-mal). Later Maliki and Shafi'i scholars ruled that where there is no fair, functioning treasury, the remainder is first returned to the sharers (radd) and then given to distant kindred. The Arabic text is on al-Maktaba al-Shamila.

Open source ↗

“The maternal uncle is the heir of one who has no heir”: hadith and commentary

The Prophet ﷺ said that the maternal uncle is the heir of one who has no heir. It is narrated by Abu Dawud, al-Tirmidhi, Ibn Majah and Ahmad. For the scholars who count distant kindred as heirs, this hadith is one of the main proofs. This page gives the Arabic text of the hadith, its grading, a plain explanation and how the estate is divided among distant kindred.

Open source ↗

Al-Mabsut (Imam al-Sarakhsi): chapter on distant kindred

Imam al-Sarakhsi's al-Mabsut is a major, authoritative work of Hanafi fiqh. This chapter sets out the Hanafi order of distant kindred: first a daughter's children, then the maternal grandfather, then the children of brothers and sisters, then paternal aunts and maternal uncles and aunts. It also records the difference that Imam Abu Hanifa puts the maternal grandfather before the siblings' children, while Imam Abu Yusuf and Imam Muhammad put the siblings' children first. The Arabic text is in the IslamWeb library.

Open source ↗

Egyptian Dar al-Ifta, fatwa 3145: maternal uncle, maternal aunt and paternal aunt

This is fatwa no. 3145 of Egypt's official Dar al-Ifta, given by Mufti Dr Ali Gomaa. It answers the case where the heirs are a maternal uncle, a maternal aunt and a paternal aunt. The paternal aunt receives two-thirds, and the maternal uncle and aunt together one-third, the uncle receiving twice the aunt. This is the division that results from putting the father's side in the father's place and the mother's side in the mother's place.

Open source ↗

Dividing between a brother's daughters and a sister's children

This is an English fatwa from Islamic Portal (UK) on dividing an estate between a brother's daughters and a sister's children. The answer cites Hanafi works such as al-Fatawa al-Hindiyya and Lisan al-Hukkam. It explains the difference between the methods of Imam Abu Yusuf, who looks at the relatives themselves, and Imam Muhammad, who looks at their parents. Our family tree shows Imam Muhammad's result and, where it differs, Imam Abu Yusuf's as well.

Open source ↗

Shaykh Abd al-Aziz ibn Baz: chapter on the inheritance of distant kindred

This is an Arabic audio lesson by the Saudi scholar Shaykh Abd al-Aziz ibn Baz. It explains the tanzil method of dividing among distant kindred: each relative is put in the place of the heir through whom they are connected to the deceased, for example the maternal grandfather in the mother's place. In this method men and women receive equally. Our Hanbali calculation follows this method.

Open source ↗

Hanafi fiqh followed in Pakistan

Shahbaz Ahmad Cheema · Pakistan Journal of Islamic Research, Volume 22, Issue 1

This is an article by Shahbaz Ahmad Cheema in the Pakistan Journal of Islamic Research on following Hanafi fiqh in Pakistan. We cite it for the point that most people in Pakistan follow Hanafi fiqh and that the courts here generally follow Hanafi fiqh in inheritance matters. That is why the Hanafi rule on distant kindred matters in Pakistan.

Open the paper ↗

When there is no heir, or only a husband or wife

After the fixed shares and the residuaries, the remaining estate goes in this order: first radd to fixed-share relatives other than the husband or wife, then to the distant kindred, and last to the public treasury. The Hanbali book Kashshaf al-Qina states that radd and the distant kindred come before the public treasury.

Only a husband or wife, and no distant relative either

  • Hanafi, original view: Imam al-Sarakhsi writes in al-Mabsut that when the only heir is a husband or wife, the remainder goes to the public treasury.
  • Hanafi, ruling of later scholars: Allamah Ibn Abidin reports in Radd al-Muhtar that in our time, because the public treasury has become corrupt, the ruling is to return the remainder to the husband and wife, and al-Mustasfa says that this is the ruling today and the view of the later Hanafi scholars. On this ruling the husband or wife receives the whole estate.
  • Hanbali: According to Kashshaf al-Qina the wife receives one quarter and the husband one half, and the rest belongs to the public treasury.
  • Maliki and Shafii: In the original school view the remainder belongs to the public treasury. Where the treasury is not justly run, later scholars hold radd first and then the distant kindred. Returning the remainder to the husband or wife is also reported from some later Shafii scholars.

Where there is no public treasury at all, such as a non-Muslim country

According to a Shafii fatwa, the property of a Muslim with no heir belongs to the Muslim treasury, and if there is no treasury, upright Muslims should distribute it among the poor and needy. In non-Muslim countries local law often divides inheritance its own way, or the government takes heirless property. That is why scholars have said a Sharia-compliant will is essential for Muslims living there.

The safest course: a will during one's lifetime

In Hanafi fiqh someone with no heir may bequeath all their property, and the bequest takes effect. Radd al-Muhtar says it is better for such a person to give charity with their own hand and then bequeath the rest. Someone whose only heir is a husband or wife may bequeath up to one third; for more, consult a scholar.

Fiqh Jafari: If only the husband is left, he receives the whole estate: his half share and the rest as radd. If only the wife is left, she receives one quarter and the rest is the right of the Imam (peace be upon him); for how it is spent, one refers to one's marja of taqlid. If there is no heir at all, the whole estate is the right of the Imam.

Sources for this section

Returning the remainder to husband and wife: scholars' statements

This is an Arabic lesson on IslamWeb on who takes the remainder when the only heir is the husband or the wife. It cites Radd al-Muhtar (vol. 6, p. 788), al-Mustasfa and al-Haddad. According to them, later Hanafi scholars ruled for returning the remainder to the husband or wife because the public treasury had broken down, so the spouse receives the whole estate.

Open source ↗

Property of a person with no heir: Hanafi references

This is an English fatwa in the Hanafi section of IslamQA on what happens to the property of someone with no heirs. The answer cites the Hanafi works al-Mabsut, al-Fatawa al-Hindiyya and Radd al-Muhtar. It is the source of the Hanafi view on this page: such property belongs to the public treasury, and such a person may make a will for the whole of their property.

Open source ↗

Hanbali: reference to Kashshaf al-Qina

This is Arabic fatwa no. 323498 on IslamQA, citing the authoritative Hanbali work Kashshaf al-Qina'. If the only heir is the husband or the wife, the husband receives half and the wife a quarter, and the rest goes to the public treasury. It also makes clear that return to sharers (radd) and distant kindred both come before the treasury.

Open source ↗

Shafii fatwa: property of a Muslim with no heir

This is an English fatwa according to the Shafi'i school (Qibla Shafi'i). The property of a Muslim with no heir belongs to the Muslims' public treasury. Where there is no treasury at all, as in a non-Muslim country, righteous Muslims should distribute it among the poor and needy.

Open source ↗

The need for a will in a non-Muslim country

This is an Arabic paper by Dr Mustafa Sulayman Kamil for the Assembly of Muslim Jurists of America (AMJA) on inheritance between people of different religions. It discusses Muslims living in non-Muslim countries, where local law divides estates its own way or the state takes heirless property. That is why scholars have said Muslims living there must write an Islamic will.

Open source ↗

The Fiqh Jafari system of inheritance

The inheritance of Shia (Twelver) Muslims follows Fiqh Jafari. The fixed shares of the Quran are the same, but the order of heirs and the rules for the remainder differ. In the family tree, choose “Fiqh Jafari” at the top and the whole calculation follows these rules. The calculation follows chapter 38 of Ayatollah Sayyid Ali al-Sistani's book Islamic Laws (Tawdih al-Masail).

The three classes of heirs

  • First class: Father, mother and children; with no children, the son's and daughter's children, who take their parent's place.
  • Second class: Paternal and maternal grandparents, and siblings; with no siblings, their children.
  • Third class: Paternal uncles and aunts, maternal uncles and aunts; with none of them, their children.

As long as a single heir of a higher class is present, the lower class does not inherit. A husband or wife inherits with every class.

Key differences

  • There is no separate rule of residuaries: the surplus after the fixed shares is returned to the same blood relatives in proportion to their shares, not to the husband or wife. For example, with only the father, the mother and one daughter, the estate is divided into five parts: one to the father, one to the mother, three to the daughter.
  • If the shares exceed the estate there is no awl; the shortfall falls on the share of the daughters or sisters.
  • With no children the mother receives one third of the whole estate. If there are two brothers, or one brother and two sisters, or four sisters, and the father is alive, the mother's share falls to one sixth, while these siblings do not inherit themselves.
  • In the second and third classes the mother's-side relatives receive one third (one sixth for a single maternal half-sibling), divided equally between men and women; the father's-side relatives receive the rest, a male receiving twice a female. The share of a husband or wife is taken from the father's side.
  • A husband alone takes the whole estate. A wife alone receives one quarter and the rest is the right of the Imam (peace be upon him).
  • In Ayatollah Sistani's view a wife does not inherit land, and inherits only the value of buildings and trees. Some other jurists apply this only to a childless widow.
  • Where Ayatollah Sistani has told the heirs to settle (for example when a maternal uncle and aunt are both present), the tree does not produce a percentage but shows that guidance instead.

In Pakistan

Pakistani courts decide the inheritance of Shia families according to Fiqh Jafari. For example, the Lahore High Court case Khalida Shamim Akhtar v Ghulam Jaffar (PLD 2016 Lahore 865) concerned the share of the childless widow of a Shia husband. Each Shia family should act on the fatwa of its own marja, since the marjas differ in places.

Sources for this section

Ayatollah Sistani: Islamic Laws, chapter 38 (inheritance)

This is chapter 38, on inheritance, of Ayatollah Sayyid Ali al-Sistani's Islamic Laws (Tawdih al-Masa'il), in English on his office's official website. Ruling 2745 sets out the three classes of heirs; rulings 2748 to 2756 cover the first class (parents and children), 2757 to 2772 the second (grandparents and siblings), 2773 to 2780 the third (paternal and maternal uncles and aunts), and 2781 to 2790 the husband and wife. Our Fiqh Jafari calculation follows these rulings.

Three classes ↗ First class ↗ Second class ↗ Third class ↗ Husband and wife ↗

When there is only a husband or only a wife

This is the inheritance section of a book by Ayatollah Sayyid Muhammad Husayn Fadlallah (ruling 1577, English translation). It gives the ruling when the deceased's only heir is the husband or only the wife. It is listed here as a second jurist's reference, because the rulings of jurists can differ on this point. Each family should follow the ruling of its own marja'.

Open source ↗

Al-Kafi (Shaykh al-Kulayni): when the only heir is the husband or the wife

Al-Kafi by Shaykh al-Kulayni is a hadith collection, one of the four core books of Shia hadith. The first hadith of chapter 25 reports from Imam Muhammad al-Baqir (peace be upon him) that a woman with no heir other than her husband leaves her whole estate to him. The third hadith of chapter 26 says that a man whose only heir is his wife leaves her a quarter, and the rest is the Imam's right. The book is on the Thaqalayn website, and the Arabic text with Urdu translation is also on our Sources page.

Husband only ↗ Wife only ↗ Original text and translation

Sharai al-Islam (al-Muhaqqiq al-Hilli) and Jawahir al-Kalam

Shara'i' al-Islam by al-Muhaqqiq al-Hilli is counted among the core books of Fiqh Jafari. Its last part covers the rules of inheritance (fara'id). Its best-known commentary is Jawahir al-Kalam by Shaykh Muhammad Hasan al-Najafi. This link is an English introduction to the book on WikiShia, not the text itself.

Book introduction ↗

Khalida Shamim Akhtar v Ghulam Jaffar (PLD 2016 Lahore 865)

This is the Lahore High Court case Khalida Shamim Akhtar v Ghulam Jafar (PLD 2016 Lahore 865), on the share of the childless widow of a Shia husband. The link is to Nimra Arshad's comment in the LUMS Law Journal discussing this judgment and the widow's right of inheritance. It shows that Pakistani courts decide the inheritance of Shia families under Fiqh Jafari. A detailed summary of the judgment is also in our court decisions.

Open source ↗

Inheritance of an unborn child

If, at someone's death, a child is in the mother's womb who would be an heir once born, for example the deceased's own child, that child can also share in the inheritance. The jurists set two conditions:

  1. The pregnancy existed at the time of death. Classical books state the proof as the child being born within six months of the death, with further detail for longer periods in some situations.
  2. The child is born alive. A stillborn child does not inherit. There is agreement that a child who cries out at birth inherits, because the Prophet ﷺ said that when a newborn cries out, it inherits. The jurists differ over other signs of life.

Evidence: Proof of a newborn's live birth (hadith) · Book of inheritance: the two conditions for an unborn child to inherit

When should the estate be divided?

The safest course is to delay division until the child is born. If the heirs want to divide earlier, the classical rule is to hold back the largest possible share for the unborn child. Once the child's sex and number are known after birth, the child receives its actual right, and whatever is left of the reserve is divided among the other heirs according to their shares. The same point appears in the chapter on pregnancy in the versified text al-Nuniyyah on inheritance. See the text

Ultrasound and modern medical reports

According to modern research, a medical report showing the child's sex and number removes several of the old assumptions, and the share held back before division can be set in light of a reliable medical report. But no machine can remove the possibility of a live or still birth, so that assumption always remains. With twins or more, the scenarios multiply according to whether each child is born alive or not.

In our Inheritance calculator choose the pregnancy case and all these possible scenarios are shown separately.

Pakistani law

  • In Pakistan the inheritance of Muslims follows the Sharia, so both conditions above apply here too. We did not find a separate statutory provision or a direct Supreme Court ruling on the inheritance of an unborn child.
  • Qanun-e-Shahadat 1984, Article 128: A child born during the marriage (at least six months after the marriage), or within two years after the marriage ends while the mother has not remarried, is conclusive proof of being the husband's legitimate child. The parentage of a child born after the father's death, and through it the child's inheritance, is established by this rule. In PLD 2015 SC 327 the Supreme Court held that a court cannot allow evidence to be given to disprove the legitimacy of a child born within this period.
  • Practical advice: When preparing the list of heirs for a succession certificate from NADRA or a court, always mention the pregnancy. If the certificate was issued before the child's birth, consult a lawyer. How to get the NADRA certificate

Dr Maryam al-Tamimi's study: a summary

This study by Dr Maryam bint Rashid Salih al-Tamimi (Imam Abdulrahman Bin Faisal University, Dammam) was published in 2019 in King Saud University's Journal of Islamic Studies. Its question is this: when modern devices such as ultrasound can reveal the sex and number of an unborn child, which of the jurists' old hypotheses fall away and which remain?

The study has three parts: the definition of pregnancy and the conditions for the unborn to inherit; the inheritance of a single child (boy or girl); and the inheritance of more than one child, namely children of the same sex, a boy and a girl together, and conjoined twins. Each case is calculated in tables.

Main findings of the study

  1. After the third month, devices can reveal the sex and number of the unborn, so the hypotheses about boy or girl and about the number of children are no longer needed.
  2. If the pregnancy is in the first third of its term, the heirs should wait some days so that the medical information becomes accurate. If waiting is not possible, the division follows the jurists' old method with all the hypotheses.
  3. Even when the sex and number are certain, the hypothesis of the child being born alive or dead remains, because no machine can decide it.
  4. If there is a single child of known sex, there are only two cases: born alive or born dead.
  5. With two children of the same sex there are three cases: both alive, one alive, or both dead.
  6. With one boy and one girl there are four cases: both alive, only the boy alive, only the girl alive, or both dead.
  7. As the number of children grows, so do these cases. For example, with three girls there are four cases: all three alive, two alive, one alive, or all three dead.
  8. With three or more children, firm confirmation of the number is essential. It is sometimes not clear in the third or fourth month, so it is better to wait until the fifth and sixth months, when the information is more accurate and an expert confirms it.
  9. The medical report can be relied on especially when, at the time of death, the pregnancy is in the middle stage (fourth to sixth month) or the final stage (seventh month and after); or when it is beyond the third month and there is a single child. At the very beginning, especially with more than one child, some doubt remains.
  10. With conjoined twins, the share of two persons is held as a precaution. After birth, if each has a separate brain and heart they are two persons even if some organs are shared; if organs such as the brain and heart are shared, they count as one person, because the death of one is the death of the other.

An example solved in the study

A man died. His wife is pregnant and, according to the medical report, carries two conjoined boys; there is also a daughter. The estate was divided into 120 parts: 15 to the wife (one eighth), 21 to the daughter for now, and 42 held for each twin. After birth, if they are found to be two separate persons, each receives 42 parts; if they count as one person, they receive 70 and the daughter 14 more (35 in all); and if both are born dead, the held amount goes to the daughter and her share becomes 105 (60 as her fixed share and 45 by return).

Recommendations of the study

  • Juristic research should be linked to people's practical lives and new situations.
  • Attention should be given to practical questions and their calculation in the science of inheritance, since that is its real benefit.
  • If the heirs want to divide before the birth, modern medical reports should be used, especially when the information is firm and a reliable report exists.
  • The report on sex and number should come from more than one source, to rule out deception and add caution.

In our family tree , under “Special situations”, calculates a pregnancy for one child in this same way: two cases (born alive or dead) when the sex is known, and three when it is not.

Permission to translate: The text above is our own summary of Dr Maryam al-Tamimi's study, not a word-for-word translation. We have asked the publisher (King Saud University) for permission to publish a full Urdu translation of the study. As soon as permission is received, the full Urdu translation will be published on this website.

Research sources for this section

Inheritance of a pregnancy revealed by modern medical devices: its calculation and assumptions

Dr Maryam bint Rashid Salih al-Tamimi, Imam Abdulrahman Bin Faisal University, Dammam · Journal of Islamic Studies, King Saud University, Riyadh · vol. 31, issue 3 (2019), pages 65 to 102

This 2019 study asks which of the old assumptions in inheritance fall away once modern equipment such as ultrasound shows the sex and number of the unborn children. Its conclusion: the assumptions about boy or girl and about the number of children are no longer needed, but the possibility of a live or still birth always remains. A detailed summary of the study is above in this section.

Original paper (Arabic) ↗ Full issue (Arabic) ↗

The effect of modern medical technology on the inheritance of an unborn child

Dr Siham Abdullah Saber · Journal of the Faculty of Islamic and Arabic Studies for Women, Damanhour, Al-Azhar University · Volume 7, Issue 2 (2022), pages 407 to 496

This is a 2022 Arabic paper in a journal of al-Azhar University on how modern medical technology affects the calculation of an unborn child's inheritance. It is listed as a second study supporting what this section says about ultrasound and medical reports. The Urdu text of this section is our own summary of these papers, not a literal translation.

Original paper (Arabic) ↗

The effect of modern medical means on precautionary inheritance: pregnancy and mass deaths

Sebha University Journal, Libya · Volume 3, Issue 1 (2024)

This is a 2024 Arabic paper in the journal of Sebha University, Libya, on how modern medical means affect precautionary inheritance: the cases where a share is held back because something is not known for certain, such as pregnancy and deaths that happen together. It too is listed as further research supporting this section.

Original paper (Arabic) ↗

The Urdu text of this section is our own summary of these papers, not a literal translation.

New special-circumstance report: Includes available conditional calculations for pregnancy, a missing heir and bequests, plus a separate branch quota under section 4. Other unknown or unsupported cases receive a report of the evidence and facts required. Legal and jurisprudential limits

What does this edition include?

23 defined relationship groups, ordinary fixed shares, exclusion by close relatives, the basic order of residuary heirs, the two ‘Umariyya cases, ‘awl, an explicit radd policy, the well-known paternal-grandmother difference, Mushtaraka, Akdariyya and the general branch for a grandfather with one type of siblings. Fractions are calculated using integers; rounding of final currency units is explained separately.

Which cases require further review?

Pregnancy, missing persons, simultaneous deaths or an unknown order of deaths, different religions, disputed parentage or homicide as an impediment, distant kindred, generations or relationships outside the list, statutory rights of children of predeceased children, and bequests requiring consent. A single answer requires further information and the relevant jurisprudence/law.

We wrote this calculation ourselves, based on Arabic books of inheritance law, hadith and published fatwas. Not every disputed opinion in the books or every court scenario is covered.

See all references →
Important note

This research is drawn from the Holy Quran (especially Surah al-Nisa 4:11, 4:12 and 4:176), the hadith (Sahih al-Bukhari, Sahih Muslim, Sunan Abi Dawud, Jami al-Tirmidhi) and the recognised books of each school: Hanafi (al-Mabsut, Radd al-Muhtar, al-Fatawa al-Hindiyya), Maliki and Shafii (al-Mawsuah al-Fiqhiyyah and the books of those schools), Hanbali (Kitab al-Faraid, Kashshaf al-Qina, Shaykh Ibn Baz), and Fiqh Jafari (Ayatollah Sistani's Tawdih al-Masail). For Pakistani law, judgments of the Supreme Court, the Federal Constitutional Court, the Federal Shariat Court and the High Courts, and NADRA's official website, have been consulted. Every statement is given with its source and link.

Anyone who disagrees with any part of this research, or wants more detail on their own school, should consult scholars near them. All references · Sources

Educational and research edition · 15 November 2026. Results depend on the entered relationships and the stated jurisprudential approach. Before actual distribution, verify the complete family circumstances, ownership, debts and applicable law with qualified scholars and a legal professional.

FAROOQ MUGHAL (SMC-PRIVATE) LIMITED · The name and original logo belong to their respective owner.